Star Trek Storylines That Grew to become Unwatchable With Age

Gene Roddenberry’s optimistic area opera “Star Trek” debuted in September 1966, and it wasn’t a success. “Star Trek,” whereas visually putting sufficient to warrant tales in TV information, struggled by way of its first few years, not often bringing within the sorts of blockbuster numbers that NBC would have favored. Certainly, many Trekkies can inform you that “Star Trek” solely lasted into its third season because of a concerted letter-writing marketing campaign from followers, begging that it’s stored on the air. “Star Trek” would not turn out to be fashionable till it was in syndication within the Nineteen Seventies. Reruns allowed a brand new viewers of obsessives to find it, and ultimately, “Star Trek” conventions started to kind. “Star Trek” has been a pop phenomenon ever since. 

However like several long-running pop phenomenon, typically the creators run low on concepts. Certainly, longtime watchers of “Star Trek” can possible level to complete seasons the place the screenwriters had been wrestling with tales, attempting to get one thing, something on display screen earlier than the week was up. Lots of “Star Trek” plots do not make sense upon their fiftieth viewings, and Trekkies have made a complete cottage trade over nitpicking. 

And, as a result of the franchise is 58 years previous (as of 2024), not all of the tales are going to have aged nicely. Certainly, a number of episodes are repeatedly lambasted by Trekkies because the worst the franchise has to supply, typically as a result of they now not replicate the values of the trendy day, and typically as a result of that they had dangerous values that solely turn out to be worse looking back. Listed below are 5 examples of “Star Trek” tales that aged poorly. 

“Turnabout Intruder” (June 3, 1969) was the ultimate episode of the unique “Star Trek” collection, and it is lengthy been held as one of many present’s very worst. In it, a bitter ex-lover of Captain Kirk (William Shatner), a health care provider named Janice Lester (Sandra Smith), has found a expertise that permits her to commerce consciousnesses with one other individual. Dr. Lester lures Kirk to the brain-switching machine and usurps his physique, hoping to take over the usS. Enterprise. 

Her motivation for stealing the Enterprise comes from the Starfleet coverage that girls usually are not allowed to function starship captains, a sexist conceit that does not slot in with the ordinarily accepting philosophy of the Federation. This element is overtly and resoundingly ignored by Trekkies and is mostly not thought-about canon, regardless of being talked about in dialogue. The episode continues with its sexism, nevertheless, by presenting the Kirk-occupying Dr. Lester as “too emotional” to steer, and too susceptible to female trickery. The episode in the end argues that girls who search positions of energy are loopy. 

/Movie lately declared “Turnabout Intruder” to be the worst episode of “Star Trek,” citing the above causes. The story is well-told, and each Sandra Smith and William Shatner give nice performances taking part in two characters every, however the sexist concepts behind it are too offensive to be ignored. It is so unusual that “Star Trek,” a collection that argued in opposition to bigotry and in favor of multiculturalism, can be so regressive.

And talking of sexism, one needn’t look too far previous “Angel One” (January 25, 1988) to seek out misogyny within the period of “Star Trek: The Subsequent Era.” Additionally declared one of many worst episodes of its collection by /Movie, “Angel One” sees the usS. Enterprise-D visiting the titular colony that has been arrange as a matriarchy. The ladies are tall and bodily robust, whereas the lads are small and effeminate. Already, “Angel One” appears to be arguing that measurement and bodily energy are required for girls to be thought-about rulers. 

The chief of the Angel colony, Beata (Karen Montgomery) turns into enamored of Commander Riker (Jonathan Frakes) and tries to seduce him. She can also be wrestling with a separatist motion that needs to say gender equality. Beata sees them as a menace and goals to have the lads within the motion executed. It takes a talking-to from Riker to elucidate that her society will now not be matriarchal or patriarchal, however equal. 

The episode, like “Turnabout Intruder,” argues that girls wishing to be in positions of energy are cussed and imply. One can see that “Star Trek” was attempting to depict a gender-flipped model of misogyny, however given how a lot sexism nonetheless exists on the earth, it is onerous to not see “Angel One” as simply being sexist unto itself. 

The unique concept for “Code of Honor” (October 12, 1987) was imagined to characteristic a species of reptilian aliens that had adopted a code of honor impressed by the Bushido code utilized by medieval samurai. Because the script was developed, nevertheless, the reptilians gave method to extra humanoid aliens. Sadly, it was the episode’s unique director, Russ Mayberry, who determined to solid all Black actors because the aliens, the Ligonians. The casting, in addition to their costumes, made the Ligonians learn as racial stereotypes, seemingly culled from dated, racist Forties “Darkest Africa” model media. The Ligonians had been a regressive society that believed in kidnapping their brides and in trials by fight, making the stereotyping even worse. 

The story goes that Mayberry was fired midway by way of the episode, forcing Les Landau to finish the episode. Mayberry was, it appears, fired over the casting, so even the makers of “Subsequent Era” knew they had been doing one thing tasteless. As a result of “Subsequent Era” was so younger at this level in its run, and since it was produced at such a breakneck tempo, there was no method to merely scrap the episode and begin once more. So “Code of Honor” went to air, stereotypes intact, pleasing nobody. This one has continued to age badly, and it too is commonly listed as one of many worst “Star Trek” episodes of all time. 

By way of its story, the “Star Trek: Voyager” episode  “Tattoo” (November 6, 1995) is simply nice. Chakotay (Robert Beltran) finds symbols on a distant alien planet that coincidentally resembles the tattoo on his temple. He investigates the image whereas storms rage overhead, placing the usS. Voyager in peril. He ultimately finds a tribe of alien natives, all with matching tattoos, who clarify that they visited Earth many hundreds of years earlier than, and gifted the First Nation individuals with an alien widget. The aliens assumed that the First Nation individuals had been all killed off, and so they have been defensive ever since. Chakotay explains that people have advanced and do not commit genocide anymore. “Tattoo” is not terribly inventive, nevertheless it’s within the spirit of “Star Trek.” 

The explanation “Tattoo” has aged poorly is due to what we now know in regards to the Chakotay character. The makers of “Voyager” employed a person named Jamake Highwater as a advisor on American Indian tradition, hoping Highwater may make Chakotay’s tradition correct. Highwater, it could ultimately be revealed, was not Cherokee as he claimed, and his data of First Nation individuals was wholly invented. Highwater was uncovered as early as 1984, however producers stored hiring him. Highwater handed away in 2001. 

As such, it is onerous to take the First Nation spirituality on show in “Voyager” terribly critically. What as soon as felt like optimistic illustration turned out to be one other type of stereotyping. Chakotay’s tribe was listed in “Tattoo,” and it is solely imaginary. “Star Trek: Prodigy” would ultimately re-declare Chakotay to be Nicarao.

The third season of “Star Trek: Enterprise” kicked off with a grim bang in an episode known as “The Xindi” (September 10, 2003). A mysterious unmanned weapon appeared in orbit round Earth and proceeded to obliterate the state of Florida. A species known as the Xindi took credit score, which was unusual, and nobody on Earth had ever heard of the Xindi. The usS. Enterprise was known as again to Earth, took on a complement of navy roughnecks, and took to the celebrities to analyze who the Xindi had been and, extra importantly, introduced them to violent justice. 

The third season of “Enterprise” was clearly meant to be a metaphor for 9/11, and sought to replicate the violence and chaos that the world was residing in 2003. The issue with “The Xindi,” and the explanation the episode hasn’t aged nicely, is that “Enterprise” seemingly had no viewpoint about its personal vengeful rage. Lots of the world was feeling offended and vengeful after 9/11, and america began a number of wars in consequence. “Star Trek,” a notoriously pacifistic collection, tried to recapture that warlike wrath however did not fairly succeed. Many viewers might have seen themselves within the offended Captain Archer (Scott Bakula), however “Enterprise” by no means may determine if Archer’s anger was useful and environment friendly, or a serious failing of his character. 

With most social points, the “Star Trek” viewpoint is normally a progressive one. Struggle is dangerous. Individuals deserve rights. Slavery is evil. “The Xindi,” in attempting to be topical and instant, did not have the luxurious of perspective. We had been nonetheless residing in a post-9/11 world, and the writers of “Enterprise” could not develop an ethical stance on something. 

The plots and characters are all nice, however the attitudes are very a lot of their time.